You have to start somewhere. Traveling to Berlin last week
to begin a five-month stay, I read a book about Albert Einstein -- the circumstances in which he moved to Berlin in 1914,
and those in which, 18 years later, he left -- three weeks before
Adolf Hitler became chancellor. "Take a good look,"
he said to his wife, as they closed up their summer cottage.
"You will never see it again."
Berlin in 1914 was one of five great cities of the world, on
a par with London, Paris, Vienna and New York. "The center
of the world, if one's world were theoretical science,"
writes Thomas Levenson in Einstein
in Berlin. And Einstein, in turn, was central to Berlin's
ambition.
He had been born in 1879 in the cathedral city of Ulm in southern
Germany, about halfway between Munich and Zurich. He was the
first son in a family of long-settled "meadow Jews,"
his father an upwardly-mobile dealer in mattress feathers, his
mother the daughter of a prosperous merchant. Enrolled at Zurich's
Polytechnic Institute when he was 17, he studied basic science,
at what was otherwise an engineering school, with mixed success.
"You're a smart boy, Einstein, a very smart boy.
But you have one fault. You do not let yourself be told anything,"
growled his department head, who thereafter apparently blocked
his appointment to various research posts despite his top performance.
Thus it was that by 1902 Einstein found himself working in the
Swiss patent office in Zurich, grateful to have a dull job that
permitted him to read the physics journals and to think.
Then in the single year of 1905, Einstein wrote three papers
that demonstrated a capacity to revolutionize physics: the light
quantum hypothesis in March, an account of Brownian motion in
May, the relativity principle in June. Then in September, as
a kind of an after-thought, he wrote up the startling insight
into the deep connection between energy and mass that eventually
would be expressed in the famous summary equation, E=mc_. ("This
thought is amusing and infectious," he wrote to a friend,
"but I cannot possibly know whether the good Lord does
not laugh at it and has led me up the garden path.") By
1908 he was a professor at the University of Zurich, and in
1911, he was called to the German University in Prague and thus
promoted into the top rank of world physicists.
An extraordinary offer was required to bring Einstein to Berlin
(he had renounced his German citizenship twenty years before
to avoid military service): a faculty appointment at the University
of Berlin, with no teaching responsibilities; the directorship
of a laboratory named for him, under the imprimatur of the famous
Kaiser Wilhelm Institutes; and immediate election of the Prussian
Academy of Sciences as the youngest member. Implicit was the
promise that the powerful industrial community of Berlin stood
behind the offer. The pitch was made to Einstein at his home
in Zurich by two of the greatest scientists in the world, the
physicist Max Planck and the physical chemist Walther Nernst.
His response underscored the drama. He would require a day to
think it over. Then he would meet the Berliners the next day
on a railway platform, carrying a flower -- white if he
declined, red if he was willing to come.
Levenson is a documentary filmmaker and science writer associated
with the Public Broadcast System's "Nova" series.
He wrote his book in connection with a two-hour biography of
Einstein; it is full of fascinating stories, enough to make
it a book club selection, but his gift for the visual sometimes
shows. Einstein
in Berlin will not replace Barbara Tuchman's great
books on the transformation of Europe in the 20th
century, The Proud Tower and The Guns of August.
On the other hand, Levenson's book conveys a satisfying
answer to the question with which it begins. "What happened
to mutate this ostentatiously civilized imperial metropolis
that Einstein entered in 1914 into the city perched on the edge
of the abyss that he left for good at the end of 1932
?"
The answer, of course, is The Great War.
For the generation raised in the aftermath of World War II,
still more for those who grew up in times more distant, it is
hard now to fathom just how shattering was the discontinuity
posed by World War I. By interleaving a highly readable narrative
of the war itself an account of Einstein's experiences
during the war -- including his formulation of the general
theory of relativity -- Levenson reminds us the way in which
the war set the stage for the terrible events that came after.
Before the war, German science was superlative. Planck, Nernst
and other members of the scientific elite correctly intuited
that enormous power, economic and military, awaited those who
solved the mysteries of quantum mechanics and special relativity.
And indeed, not just the atom bomb but radar, television, semiconductors
and computers lay directly down the path that Einstein had discovered.
German science generally and Einstein himself remained in place
throughout the 1920s, amid the frustrations, humiliations and
froth of the Weimar Republic. For a dozen years, it seemed to
the best Germans as though things might get better.
Instead they got worse -- disastrously worse. In late 1932
the Nazis finally won control of the government. Before Hitler
became chancellor, Einstein and his wife slipped out of Berlin
on their way to Caltech for a semester of teaching, never to
return. The rest is tragic dénouement. Most of the most
talented people in German science left, and leadership shifted
to United States. The Einsteins moved to the Institute for Advanced
Study at Princeton; he spent the rest of his life on the sidelines.
(Levenson punctures the myth that Einstein's two letters
to President Franklin Roosevelt, signed at the urging of Hungarian
physicists Leo Szilard, Edward Teller and Eugene Wigner, was
somehow instrumental in the American decision to pursue the
fission bomb. The impetus to the Manhattan Project came from
other sources. But the mere fact that Einstein was willing to
sign it shows how far he had come from the days when he was
willing to serve as the highly public symbol of German scientific
and cultural aspirations.)
Today, Germany is the fourth most powerful economy in the world -- thanks mainly to its manufacturing prowess. But the government
is still trying to restore the delicate balance of the system
of higher education that was so badly damaged in 1932. The pronounced
German taste for equality, accentuated since East Germany and
West threw in their lot together in 1990, has produced a university
system that has a hard time keeping up with the latest developments,
much less turning them into economic activity.
The latest controversy has to do with Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder's
plans to create "elite universities" to compete with
German's ubiquitous state universities, estimable institutions
which provide top-down education to all comers, more or less
as a matter of course. As in 1914, the problem comes down to
incentives. When faculty salaries, departmental hires and student
tuitions are set by political authorities, the brightest people
in a global market will show a white flower more often than
red.
The problem is especially clear in Berlin. The city is knitting
together nicely as a political and cultural capital now, after
some hard times in the 1990s. But despite its three universities,
it still doesn't have a readily identifiable economic base.
Life sciences? Media? Maybe so. But for the moment, Berlin lacks
even a single direct flight to the United States. That's
a market signal that is hard to miss.